Every November and December, a lot of families in Greenville and the Upstate pull out the good silverware for a holiday dinner and ask the same question: is this real sterling, and is it worth anything if nobody plans to use it again? Sometimes it is a full service for twelve in a wooden chest, sometimes a handful of spoons and a pair of candlesticks. This guide walks you through how to tell sterling from silver plate, what actually counts toward the value, and how to sell sterling silver flatware in Greenville without leaving money on the table.
Step one: sterling or silver plate?
This is the question that matters most, because the two look almost identical on the table and are worth very different amounts. Sterling silver is 92.5% silver all the way through. Silver plate is a thin layer of silver over a base metal such as brass, copper or nickel silver. Plated pieces have almost no metal value.
Turn a fork or spoon over and look at the back of the handle. You are looking for one of these:
- Sterling marks: "STERLING", "STER", "925" or ".925". American sterling flatware is usually marked this way, often next to the maker's name and sometimes a pattern patent date.
- British hallmarks: a small row of stamped symbols. A walking lion (the "lion passant") means English sterling.
- Plate marks: "EP", "EPNS", "silverplate", "silver plated", "triple plate", "quadruple plate" or "A1". These mean the piece is plated, even when the word "silver" appears in the stamp.
A famous maker's name on its own does not settle it. Some well-known companies made both sterling and plated lines, so the sterling or 925 mark is what you want to find. If a piece has no mark at all, set it aside to be tested rather than guessing either way. Some of the simple checks in our guide on telling real gold from fake, like reading stamps under good light, work for silver too.
What counts toward the value of sterling flatware
When sterling is sold for its metal, it is valued by the weight of the actual silver in it. That sounds simple, but a few common pieces are not solid all the way through.
Knives
Most sterling dinner knives have a stainless steel blade set into a hollow sterling handle that is filled with a resin or cement-like filler. Only the thin silver shell of the handle counts, so a knife weighs a lot more than the silver it contains. Our sell silver page suggests counting only about 15% of a knife's weight as silver. Serving pieces with steel blades, like cake servers and carving sets, work the same way.
Weighted holloware
Candlesticks, some bowls and compotes are often marked "weighted" or "reinforced". That means a thin sterling shell has been filled with pitch, plaster or cement to make it stand steady. The silver content is a small part of the total weight. Bring them, but do not count their full weight in your own estimate.
Solid pieces
Forks, spoons, ladles, sugar tongs and most serving spoons stamped sterling are usually solid silver. These make up most of the value in a typical set, and they are the pieces to weigh first if you want a rough number at home.
How to estimate what your set is worth
You do not need a number before you call, but a rough estimate helps you judge any offer.
- Sort the pile. Make three groups: solid sterling, sterling with steel blades or filler, and plated or unmarked.
- Weigh the solid sterling in grams. A kitchen scale is fine for a rough idea. Our guide to weighing at home explains the troy ounce versus kitchen ounce mix-up, which trips up silver sellers just as often as gold sellers.
- Run the numbers. Enter the weight and purity in our silver calculator. It uses the live spot price and shows the melt value of the silver.
- Leave the plate out. Plated pieces will not move the number.
Remember that melt value is the starting point, not the offer. Any buyer pays a share of melt, and the fair ones will show you how they got from your weight to their number. See how our offers work for more.
Melt value or a collector? Know your options
Some sterling patterns are popular with people trying to complete or replace a family set, and replacement services or collectors may pay more than metal value for certain pieces in good condition. If you have a complete set in a well-known pattern and time to shop it around, it can be worth checking that route first.
Many people do not want to do that. The set has sat in a closet for years, or there are odd pieces, worn monograms and mismatched patterns. That is where selling for silver weight makes sense. It is fast, and a monogram or dent does not change the silver value. Our comparison of pawn shops, jewelers and gold buyers explains how each type of buyer tends to price precious metal.
Do not polish it first
Skip the polish. Polishing takes time, can wear down thin plate and soft detail, and it does not raise the silver weight at all. Tarnish is just a surface film, so bring your silver as it is. The same goes for silver coins: never clean coins, because cleaning can lower their value to collectors.
Selling sterling as part of an estate
Silverware often shows up when a family is settling an estate. If that is your situation, our step-by-step guide to selling inherited gold, silver and coins in the Upstate covers how to sort everything before you sell. We also buy gold jewelry, gold coins, pre-1965 US silver coins and platinum, so you can get a quote on a mixed lot at once. The what we buy page has the full list.
How selling sterling silver works with us
Call or text (864) 990-2052 for a free quote. A quote is based on weight and purity, so it helps to have your rough weight and the stamps you found. Photos of the marks are welcome, but a firm quote needs the weight.
- In person: by appointment. Schedule a time and we confirm the location when you schedule. Every piece is weighed and tested in front of you, and we show you the math.
- By mail: we also buy by mail. Flatware sets are heavy, so call first and we will walk you through how selling by mail works.
- Payment: cash, Zelle, ACH or check.
You will need a valid photo ID to sell, as with any precious metal buyer. We are open 24/7 and speak Spanish, so reach out whenever and in whichever language is easier.
Selling silverware across the Upstate
We help sellers in Greenville and throughout the Upstate. See the page for your area: Spartanburg, Greer, Simpsonville, Easley and Mauldin. We also help sellers from Anderson and Powdersville. The areas we serve page lists every town, and sell gold in Greenville, SC is the main overview.
Mistakes to avoid
- Selling sterling by the piece. A flat "per spoon" price ignores weight. Ask for the number in grams or troy ounces.
- Counting knives and candlesticks at full weight. Steel blades and filler are not silver.
- Taking the first offer under pressure. A fair buyer lets you think it over. Our cash-for-gold red flags apply to silver too.
Frequently asked questions
Is my silverware sterling or silver plated?
Look on the back of the handle. "Sterling", "Ster" or "925" means sterling. "EP", "EPNS", "silverplate" or "quadruple plate" means plated. English pieces may carry a walking lion hallmark instead. If there is no mark, it should be tested.
Is silver plated flatware worth selling?
For metal value, very little. The silver layer is very thin. Plated sets are usually better kept, donated or sold as household items.
Do sterling knives count toward the weight?
Only the handle does, and most of it is filler. A common rule of thumb is to count about 15% of a sterling knife's total weight as silver.
Should I polish my silver before selling it?
No. Polishing does not add any silver weight. Bring it tarnished and as it is.
Does a monogram lower the value?
Not when silver is sold for its weight. A monogram can matter to a collector, but it does not change the amount of silver in the piece.
Do you buy silver coins too?
Yes. We buy pre-1965 US silver coins, silver bars and rounds, and silver jewelry, along with gold and platinum. Please do not clean coins before selling.
How do I get paid?
By cash, Zelle, ACH or check.
Have a chest of silver you are ready to part with? Call or text (864) 990-2052 for a free quote, or check its melt value first with our silver calculator.