Clearing out a parent’s or grandparent’s home is hard enough without trying to figure out what the jewelry box is worth. Across Greenville, Spartanburg, Anderson and the rest of the Upstate, families find the same things: a mix of real gold and costume pieces, a few coins in a cigar box, a silver tea set that has not been polished in decades, and no idea which is which.
This guide walks you through the order to do things in, what to keep apart, what not to clean, and how to sell what you decide to sell without leaving money on the table. It is general information, not legal or tax advice, and we point out the places where you should talk to an attorney or tax professional.
Step 1: Make sure you have the right to sell
Before anything leaves the house, make sure the person selling has the authority to sell. If the estate is going through probate, the personal representative (sometimes called the executor) is usually the person who can sell estate property. If the jewelry was left to a specific family member in a will, it belongs to them. If you are not sure, the probate court in the county where your relative lived, such as the Greenville, Spartanburg, Anderson or Pickens County probate court, or an estate attorney can tell you what applies.
When you sell to a reputable buyer, the seller will be asked for a government-issued photo ID. State and federal rules require precious metal buyers to verify every seller, and estate sales are no exception.
Step 2: Sort before you sell anything
The single most valuable thing you can do is sort. Lay everything out on a towel on the kitchen table and make piles.
- Marked gold. Look for 10K, 14K, 18K or the numbers 417, 585 or 750 inside ring bands, on clasps and on the back of pendants. Our karat guide lists every stamp.
- Marked silver. “Sterling,” “925” or “STER” on flatware, bowls and jewelry. Silver-plated pieces are often marked “EPNS,” “Silverplate” or with a maker’s name and the word “plate.”
- Coins. Keep them in whatever holder or envelope they came in.
- Unmarked or uncertain pieces. Many older pieces and items made outside the US have no stamp. Do not throw these out; they still need testing.
- Clearly costume. Plastic, glass beads and pieces marked “GP,” “GF,” “HGE” or “RGP” (gold-plated or gold-filled). These have little or no gold value, though some costume pieces are collectible.
- Sentimental keepers. Decide as a family which pieces are not for sale before anyone gets an offer. It is much easier than deciding under pressure.
Our article on how to tell if gold is real at home has quick tests you can use while sorting.
Step 3: Do not clean, polish or break anything up
It is tempting to shine everything up before selling. Don’t, especially with coins. Cleaning a coin can permanently lower its collector value, sometimes by far more than the gold in it. Polishing old silver removes patina that some buyers value. And do not pry stones out of rings or cut chains apart; a buyer can do that safely if needed, and an intact piece is easier to evaluate.
Step 4: Separate coins into bullion and collectible
Coins are where inherited collections hide the most value, and where sellers make the most expensive mistakes.
Bullion coins
Modern bullion coins are valued mostly by their metal content. Common examples include American Gold Eagles, American Gold Buffalos, Canadian Maple Leafs and South African Krugerrands. A 1 ounce Gold Eagle or Krugerrand contains one troy ounce of pure gold, alloyed to 22 karat for durability. These sell close to spot price because there is no guesswork. See our gold coins page for how we price them.
Pre-1933 US gold coins
US gold coins struck before 1933, such as $2.50, $5, $10 and $20 pieces, are 90% gold. Common dates in circulated condition trade close to their gold value. Scarce dates, rare mint marks and high-grade examples can be worth much more, so have these looked at by someone who knows coins before you accept a melt price.
Silver coins
US dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 or earlier are 90% silver, and many families have a jar of them. Kennedy half dollars from 1965 to 1970 are 40% silver. Silver dollars, especially Morgan and Peace dollars, have both silver value and collector value. Keep these separate from modern pocket change.
Proof sets and graded coins
Coins sealed in plastic slabs from grading services such as PCGS or NGC, and original mint or proof sets in their packaging, should stay exactly as they are. The holder is part of the value.
Step 5: Get values before you decide
Once you have sorted, get a number for each pile.
- For marked gold, weigh each karat group in grams and use our gold calculator to see melt value and our estimated offer.
- For sterling flatware and holloware, the silver calculator works the same way. Remember that knives usually have a steel blade and a weighted handle, so only part of the weight is silver.
- For platinum, often found in older engagement rings and wedding bands marked “PLAT” or “950,” use the platinum calculator.
- For coins and anything that might be collectible, get a quote from a coin specialist as well as a metal buyer, and compare.
- For estate pieces with large diamonds or a famous maker’s name, a written appraisal from a jeweler may be worth the fee.
Step 6: Think about taxes, then talk to a professional
Two general points come up in almost every estate. First, inherited property generally takes a cost basis equal to its fair market value on the date of death, which often means little or no gain if it is sold soon after. Second, the IRS treats gold, silver and coins as collectibles, which can be taxed differently from other investments. Rules depend on your situation, so keep a record of what you sold, when and for how much, and ask a CPA or tax preparer how it applies to you. A dated written receipt from your buyer makes that easy.
Step 7: Choose how to sell
For most Upstate families, the simplest path is to sell the metal-value items to a gold buyer, take collectible coins to a coin specialist and keep or consign the special pieces. If you are comparing buyers, our guide to where to sell gold in Greenville explains how pawn shops, jewelers, coin dealers and gold buyers each price your items.
Estate situations are also where patience matters most. Many people are sorting a house while working full time, or handling a parent’s affairs from out of state. Bring the sorted bags to your appointment and we will go through them with you one at a time. We test and weigh every item in front of you, show you the math, and you decide piece by piece. Anything you do not want to sell goes home with you, and you are paid by cash, Zelle, ACH or check for what you do sell.
If a family member lives outside South Carolina and has inherited pieces, they can use our sell by mail service with a free quote based on weight and karat.
A simple estate checklist
- Confirm who has the authority to sell.
- Set aside sentimental pieces first.
- Sort into gold, silver, platinum, coins, uncertain and costume.
- Do not clean coins or break up jewelry.
- Weigh each karat group in grams and check melt value.
- Get a coin specialist’s view on any older or graded coins.
- Get at least two quotes for the metal-value pile.
- Keep dated receipts for your tax records.
When you are ready, get a free quote or call or text (864) 990-2052 to schedule an appointment. We serve sellers from Greenville and the Upstate. Se habla español.